Your Basket

Love It or Hate It

Cilantro has entered the chat.

One of the delightful aspects of the world of fragrance —that financiers of the industry will lament—is that there is no universally pleasing scent.

Scent is fundamentally subjective, and because it's so driven by our unconscious, harder to predict. If you and I share a social circle, we likely have similar tastes in visual aesthetics and perhaps music—but there's no telling whether we'll enjoy the same scents.

That's what I keep observing anecdotally at pop-ups where excited visitors will smell a candle and excitedly rush to their life partner. "YOU'VE GOT TO SMELL THIS!" they'll shout, only to get back a completely expressionless stare, accompanied by a baffling response, such as "It smells like ants."

There is some science to back up this idea, as we now know that scent bypasses our rational brain and pulls directly on our emotional triggers, making our reactions deeply personal and often impossible to anticipate.

I was reminded of this by the first responses to Terraces coming through from our mighty Keaper Lab (our top secret group of volunteer Keapers testing upcoming scents). We weren't totally surprised that while the average ratings were good, reactions were highly polarized.

I emphasized in my last email the centrality of our Calabrian bergamot essential oil. Its olfactive co-star is coriander, aka cilantro, an ingredient that puts into hyperfocus just how differently we each perceive scent (and taste).

For some, the smell of cilantro is green, fresh, and pleasantly earthy. For others, it registers as chemical, soapy, or even buglike. Neuroscientists believe this stark division in our perceptions may stem from both evolutionary responses to potential threats and cultural familiarity with the ingredient.

Tacos with cilantro

Is this heaven or hell for you? (Photo: Unsplash)

My advice is straightforward: if you detest cilantro, you'll probably dislike our new scent. But if you love it (or feel neutral), Terraces might become your new favorite.

Now, you may be thinking: Why develop a scent knowing that some people will hate it?

Simply put, it comes back to that first insight that it's impossible to create a scent that everyone loves. As with most things, trying to design for everyone results in an outcome that is liked by no one. We chose to create and respect that some people will declare our products are "not for them" while giving our best to helpful guide others to options they will love.

You can get a sample of Terraces and see where you fall in our Scent-to-Home sample set ($19 before current discounts - see below). Additionally, you're getting a preview sample in your April subscription shipments.

In case you missed it, we have already discounts alongside our Spring Special Release for the next few days! Details below*

On which side of the cilantro debate do you stand? Send me a quick reply!

Have a great weekend everyone,
— Harry from Keap, Steward-Owner

More on this topic

If you enjoyed this article, you might enjoy our not-quite-weekly free newsletter where we share our lessons on our journey toward our regenerative vision, product launches, and behind-the-scenes happenings.

We left social media in 2021 because we found its current mechanics didn’t align with our purpose to facilitate connection to the natural world, our loved ones, and our own spirits. Since then, our newsletter has become a vibrant place for healthy conversation around topics ranging from alternative business ownership models to happy hour cocktail recipes.

Join our free newsletter to be the first to hear about newly available scented candles, special events, and more.

What our readers say about it

“It’s very thoughtful and not sales-y like all other marketing newsletters.”

“I like reading how a business is trying to be as progressive as possible in a capitalist system.”

“I normally delete emails from businesses but with the Keap newsletter I was actually interested in reading through! Made me feel that you guys really care about us and the work you do."